INTERVIEW 1
It's been a long time in the making, but Dream Theater
returned during the later part of 1997 with a new, full-length
album called Falling Into Infinity. For a band usually
categorized as a progressive metal band, Falling Into Infinity
marked an exploration into different areas. Although the CD
features plenty of epic Dream Theater music that their devoted
audience continually demands, it also offers a new appreciation
of concise, melodic songs. With tracks like "Hollow
Years" and "Take Away My Pain," the band has the
potential to reach an even broader audience than ever before.
Guitarist John Petrucci took time from the band's busy
preparations for their tour to talk about the creativity and
relationships that sustain him as a song writer, as well as
collaborating with Desmond Child and King's X vocalist Doug
Pinnick.
So, you guys have your new album out.
Yes, we do.
A long time in the making. What's the next step? Are you getting
ready to go out on tour?
Yeah. We're setting everything up, trying to do as much promotion
as we can before we hit the road. We're going to start in America
around October 25th, and I think we'll actually start in
Connecticut, coincidentally.
Oh, really? Somebody's going to be upset with that. I'm getting
married on the 25th.
Oh, is that right?
And my fiancee and her best friend-who's coincidentally in the
wedding party-are probably the two biggest Dream Theater fans
I've ever met.
Oh, no!
In fact, we actually met at one of your shows.
Oh, cool.
At the El 'N' Gee in New London [Connecticut]. It was two years
ago when you were doing those shows around Christmas time.
I remember.
Oh, she's going to be bummed when she hears that!
Yeah. I mean, I'm not totally sure, but I think it's going to be
at Toad's [Place] on the twenty-fifth; I think that's the
starting date. But I could be wrong. That'll kick off the
American leg, and then we'll go, next year, to Europe and Asia
and South America and stuff.
You just actually got back from Brazil.
Yeah. We went there for the first time. We've never played there
and we went there before the record was out, so we concentrated
mostly on the old material. And, it went real well.
My understanding is that when you were down there, you did
smaller venues-two or three thousand seats.
Well, we did three shows, and the first two, I think, were like,
seven thousand. It was actually our biggest headlining show, and
then the last one was like, three or four thousand.
It just strikes me as rather odd, because most of the time when
you hear of any English-speaking bands, shall we say, playing in
South America, it's usually big stadium productions.
Right. Oh, totally, totally, I think that we have the potential
of growing to that level there. I mean, just seeing the
enthusiasm, never going there at all. And going down there and
doing real successful shows, I think we have the potential of
being one of those bands. There's certainly a lot of fans down
there.
Did you find that the fans down there were very familiar with
your material?
Oh, yeah, totally. Definitely. It was as if we'd been there many
times. They knew all the words and everything. It was very cool.
Which just has to be especially cool, considering that most of
the people down there probably don't speak English. Y'know, just
to hear 'em singing your songs.
Yeah, exactly.
This new album, one of the things that I like about it is the
fact that it seems more... ah, how do I put it? It seems more
concise and song-oriented, rather than long and epic. I mean,
there's stuff on there that certainly falls into that sort of
categorization, but there's a lot of stuff on there that I find
really accessible.
That's definitely true. I mean, it's definitely more
song-oriented, and I think that we tried to have a balance
because we've built our careers based on a style that we love to
do, so we're not about to change our identity or something-it's
real important to us. But I think that we all want to become
better at writing songs. And, if you can kind of create a balance
between your musical integrity and trying to write good songs,
and, in our case, challenging ourselves musically and stuff like
that, then that's a good album. That's what we tried to do.
It just seemed to me like maybe it was a step in the direction
of... not necessarily freeing yourself from the typical Dream
Theater material, but creating that option.
Yeah. I think-it's almost like a simple matter, y'know? In a lot
of our songs-'cause we've always focused in melody and
grooves-the meaning of a song has always been important to us,
but we've always kind of like, meandered a bit within that
structure. It's really funny... people would say to us, "You
can take this song and make three songs out of it." [Laughs]
And, we kind of did that on this album, literally. We'd have some
songs that were real long and had lots of changes in direction,
and we used some of those sections-take 'em out and use 'em as
whole other songs. So there's sort of a consistent vibe
throughout one song. It was kind of like, liberating to do that
because you give yourself the freedom of just pursuing a real
consistent thought and focusing in, and it was real cool.
One of the things that I think I really enjoyed about this album
is the fact that you did all the songs song-by-song.
Yeah.
I've always found in the past with Dream Theater material that it
just-it's precise, but it just seems to lack a certain amount of
emotion.
Yeah!
And this time around, it seems like you hit that right on the
head.
I think so too. I appreciate you saying that. I think that the
goal of Kevin Shirley as a producer was to bring that out-to get
more of a live element, to not over-produce. And, to do one song
at a time. It's what we wanted to do and what he wanted to do, so
each song would have a certain identity. You can do more
experimentation that way, and all the band members can be
involved-it's more of a band effort doing it that way. So
everybody's constantly playing together and making improvements
and changes together. I think if you do it that way, you loose
some of the sterilization, y'know?
I'm sure there's already a strong bond from all the years that
you guys have played together, but did you find that doing it in
a situation where you were all together, that that built up the
comraderie even more?
Yeah, definitely. I mean, that's going to happen as a result of
that, y'know? It's a cool process. Recording's a lot of fun, and
I think it's more fun when there's a real sort of positive vibe
going on with everybody at the same time.
Did you find in this case that it may have been difficult as far
as previous recording experiences [are concerned]? I always got
the impression with previous Dream Theater albums that everything
had to be so precise and on the money, and I gathered with this
time, maybe that wasn't quite so true. Was that a difficult thing
to get over?
Well, it's funny because with all our albums, we don't get really
perfectionist-minded when we record. I think we're pretty tight
because we've been playing together for a while, but things
definitely aren't perfect. They never have been in the past, and
it really wasn't any different this time around. Most of the
songs we'd already been playing-we played a few of them live. We
can play them through, so it really was the same thing. There is
a way to balance getting a performance that's the right thing
that's polished, but at the same time, that's fresh enough to
have the emotion. Like I said, I think from having the experience
of playing live and stuff, there really wasn't a change in that.
It's interesting to look at the credits and the liner notes on
this album and some of the names that are on there, particularly
Desmond Child. From his background and what he's known for, I
would've never, ever, associated him with Dream Theater.
Right, right. There's a funny story with Desmond. When I went
down to work on this song ["You Not Me"] with him, he
said that all the people on his staff, like his interns, were all
big Dream Theater fans and they were all excited that I was
coming down. It's hilarious, y'know? He's like, "Yeah, I
just met with Madonna, and I told them that if she calls, let me
know. And they were like, 'Yeah, yeah yeah.' And then I said that
you were coming down, and they were like, 'Oh, man!'"
[Laughs] It's pretty funny, things that you don't think of [like]
the way you're perceived or whatever, isn't necessarily the case.
No, not at all. I mean, my first thought when I saw the name was
thinking of the stuff that he's done with Kiss and Aerosmith and
so forth. Oh, God, what is this gonna be?! And, it was not what I
expected.
Yeah. That's cool.
Now Doug Pinnick, that was a fantastic surprise!
Yeah, I love Doug, he's awesome.
Quite frankly, I think the vocals that he did on "Lines In
The Sand" are probably the best thing he's ever done.
[Laughs] How did that come about?
Well, we wrote that song and the chorus to that song where he's
singing, we had his type of style in mind, y'know? And we were
telling James, "Kinda sing it with a Doug vibe." And
then when it came to doing the record, we were like, "Why
don't we ask Doug to do it?" Y'know, we know him, and he was
happy to do it. So we got the actual guy that inspired the part
to do it. [Laughs] And it was so cool watching him do it. We gave
him the words and he just improvised a whole bunch of takes and
it was amazing. I mean, he's so soulful.
Yeah! I mean, that's what makes that tune so interesting to me,
is that there's just such a tension between James having the
lush, high European voice, and Doug's voice being so gritty and,
as you said, soulful. It creates such a really cool tension.
Yeah, it does.
As far as working with Kevin [Shirley], I know in the past you
guys were always compared to Yes and Rush and Kansas and so
forth. That must have been kind of cool working with him,
considering that he's worked with... well, with Rush,
particularly.
Yeah, it was great, especially the stories. [Laughs] He's really
good friends with Geddy and he's really cool. He got us Rush
tickets when they played in the area. [Laughs]
Oh, that's cool. On the subject of influences and everything, it
seems kind of neat, too, [that] the guy that you got to do the
album covers-
Yeah, that was totally cool. I mean, I'm such a big Pink Floyd
fan and it's like, you look at that stuff and the Zeppelin
covers, and you're like, "Man, we'd love to work with
someone like this." And, we've thought that for a while, and
this time it actually worked out. It was cool because he fit
right into us, and we fit right into him. As soon as we told him
the title of the album, he was kind of laughing. Like, "I
think I can do something with that." It fit right in.
Well, that must be kind of cool, considering growing up and
listening to that kind of stuff, you probably never imagined,
"God, whoever did this artwork..."
I know! There's a lot of real weird things that happen as you
move on and you're able to do this professionally. And that's one
of 'em, being able to work with people like that, like you said,
you grew up admiring their work. It's amazing.
And then, all of a sudden, they're doing your album covers.
Yeah, and you're talking to the guy and you're like,
"What?"
One of the things that I think is really interesting about the
band is the level of fan devotion that you guys have. I went to a
show last year at the Strand in Providence, Rhode Island. I'm a
pretty big guy, pretty tall, and there was a guy standing behind
me [who] tapped me on the shoulder and said, "Would you mind
moving out of the way so I can see?" I'm like, "Yeah,
no problem." And he starts to tell me that he wasn't trying
to be rude pushing me aside, but he had come all the way up from,
I don't know, like South Carolina or Georgia, all the way to
Providence to see you guys. I'm sure New England isn't the only
place that you guys play live. [Laughs] It just was so
interesting to hear that somebody came that far to see you guys.
I think that's great. That's how we're able to develop and
continue to do this. I think that the fans being that dedicated
to the band and interested in what we're doing has helped us to
continue to be able to do this. And, I think them being
consistent allows us to be consistent, be ourselves. You know
what I mean? It's just like we feed off of it, and it's really,
really cool. Some of the things that you hear people say or
things like you said-somebody driving real far, or seeing so many
shows, or telling you a story on how such-and-such song or
something was a positive influence or whatever, it's just... it's
real, real cool.
It's just really strange to hear people arguing over various
performances. It almost sounds like the Grateful Dead, y'know?
It's just something I wouldn't associate with a rock band.
I know, I know. It's great. It's so wild, it really is wild. Very
cool.
Something that was pretty cool on this album is to see that John
[Myung]'s playing the Chapman Stick. And yes, I actually know
what it is! [Laughs]
[Laughs] There you go.
Was it experimental, or is it something he's played for a while?
No, he actually got it pretty recently. That's like, the
instrument for him because he's kind of an experimental kind of
guy and he likes to have a wide range of sonic capability. He
likes to play melodic chordal ideas. He plays piano-I mean, it's
just like, the perfect instrument for him.
Have you come across all the questions yet about that? Like,
"Boy, what's he playing there? A two-by-four with some
string on it?"
Yeah, right. I don't think most people really know what that is.
He hasn't played that live with us yet, but when you bring it up,
people are like, "What's that?"
As I mentioned before, how surprised I was with Desmond Child,
it's kind of interesting with your keyboard player now,
considering where he comes from and with whom he's played. It was
quite surprising, like, "Wow! He's playing with Dream
Theater?!"
Yeah. It's funny, it's like, Derek pretty much has the same
background as us-growing up listening to the same type of bands,
going to Berklee and studying music. It's just that he pursued a
different course. Whereas we formed a band, he got gigs doing the
sideman thing. It was only a matter of time until he got into a
band where he was able to write and everything else.
From my perspective, it sounds like, as far as the keyboards are
concerned, there's a lot more jazzy soulfulness, which I think
kind of lightens up the-for lack of a better word-sterility. It
just kind of makes things a little bit more human, I think.
Yeah, exactly. That's his whole vibe.
I'm curious about this whole Nightmare Cinema project.
Oh, don't be too curious. [Laughs] It's nothing.
Is that an ongoing thing, or is it just a one-time-
Well, actually, what we did one night is we decided to play a
song, just switching our instruments. I played drums and Mike
played guitar-no, bass. John played keyboards and Derek played
guitar. Y'know, it sounds horrible. But we had to call it
something, so we just like, did the reverse of our name.
So it's actually not something that's a serious, ongoing-
Oh, it's totally not serious at all! Whether or not it's ongoing
is another story. [Laughs] But it's the farthest from serious.
Actually, have you ever considered maybe doing something like
opening for yourselves?
Well, y'know, it's funny. Mike and I, we're doing a side-project
album right now with Tony Levin and Jordan Rudess. It's all
instrumental. It's real cool. It's pretty wacky, progressive
stuff. And we talked about it. "Oh, we should open for
ourselves."
That would actually be kind of cool. Something that I never
really realized before is how much of a lyricist you are. I mean,
I always just go under the assumption [of] "Okay, singer...
writes the lyrics." And it was pretty wild to go through
this album and [say], "Wow! This guy has written a lot of
the lyrics on here."
I'm real into it, y'know? I've always been into writing, and I've
always gotten into the lyrics in bands. I mean, whether it was
Marillion or Rush or Pink Floyd, they've always moved me, and I
think it's a real creative form of writing. It's something that
comes natural to me, so I love doing it.
Something that's really interesting, I think, is the song
"Take My Pain Away." Considering the subject matter,
it's pretty wild that musically, it's very upbeat.
Right. And the subject is very-it's not necessarily dark, but
it's of a very serious nature. Yeah, there is a contrasting feel
there. The song originally started out as an acoustic thing,
still with a more positive musical outlook, but a little bit
darker in the way it was presented. And this version, which is
more rhythmical, more tribal, turned out to be more poppy and
happy, so it's kind of a strange marriage there.
Yeah, very much so because, again, I had one expectation and it
didn't turn out to be what I thought it was going to be. It's
really kind of neat with this record how it just bounces through
so many things. I mean, there's stuff on here that sounds very,
very European and very... almost majestic. And then there's other
stuff that just sounds like classic Metallica. Is that a
conscious effort to encompass so many styles, or is it just
natural?
Nah, it's just natural. We're just spitting out our influences. I
mean, yeah, Metallica and hard rock metal bands and stuff, are
things that we grew up on, as well as progressive bands and
fusion and jazz and classical. So it's kind of like, we're in a
band where we give ourselves the freedom of letting all this out,
we're not just confined to doing one thing. And it's a lot of
fun. It's a lot of fun to write that way, and like I said, our
influences are pretty obvious when you hear stuff, y'know? Like,
"Oh, man that sounds like Metallica," or, "That
sounds like Floyd," but it's still us, and we have fun doing
it.
I just think it's really a positive thing in the sense that I
think there's a lot of people [that I've seen at your shows and
listening to your music] that are probably more into a hard rock,
heavy metal kind of thing, and I think that's kind of cool that
maybe you guys are the beginning point of somebody being exposed
to different styles. Unfortunately, it seems like there's a lot
of people who don't follow where something came from. "It's
not Metallica, so it's no good. It sucks."
Yeah.
One of the things I'm curious about is the significance of the
title. Where did that come from?
Well, the name of the band being Dream Theater, we've used a lot
of imagery having to do with dreams and drama and stuff.
"Falling Into Infinity" is sort of a metaphor for like,
entering into a state of dreaming where anything's possible. And
that's kind of how we view the band and our writing process, so
that's basically where that one came from.
I'd also like to ask you about the song "Peruvian
Skies." What is the incident that that's based on?
It's based on... sort of about, like, child abuse, potential
child abuse topic. As you're reading the lyrics or going through
it, it's sort of from the perspective of someone that's on the
outside that detects something might be happening, and how
they're sort of dealing with it.
That must have been a really strange subject to write about,
considering that you have children.
Yeah! It's weird. Y'know, some things you really get into, and
some things, as a writer, you remove yourself from. Something
like "Take Away My Pain" is very personal, and it
really comes from deep within, and letting it out is like... it's
sort of a therapy. Then there's like, a fictional side that's
just a fun thing of writing. And you can write about stuff that
you don't have any experience in, whether it be dark or whatever.
That's half the fun of being creative.
Having a family now, how has that changed... I guess, even just
the way you look at things. When I think of a rock band, I don't
think of a guy with a family life. And apparently, all of you
guys are pretty well settled down.
Yeah, totally. I mean, it's always something that I've wanted to
do. I've always wanted to have children and I think it's
wonderful. I mean, I can't imagine life any other way. The
relationship that I have with my wife, and now with my kids, has
been inspiring beyond what I could imagine. So far as creatively,
it's like your life and your whole perspective and your
enrichment changes drastically. Obviously, being someone who has
to tour and stuff like that, that's something that has to be
worked out. It's a balance that has to try to be kept so you're
there. That's the hard part, but I can't imagine-I don't think
I'd get as far if I was just by myself.
I know what you mean, because I think maybe that's just a part of
growing up. When you're younger, you feel invincible and you
think that you can take on the world on your own.
Yeah. Y'know, it's wild-whether it's in music or any other form
of entertainment, or art, or business, most people have families
and children, and it's like their center of their life. It
doesn't matter what they do. But, it's cool.
Well, I don't think I have any other questions.
Let me ask you something. You're saying that your fiancee and her
friend were real big Dream Theater fans?
Absolutely.
What's their reaction to this album? I'm curious from fans'
perspective.
Y'know what? To be honest with you, they haven't had a chance to
listen to it, because I've been listening to it, boning up on it.
Uh-oh!
I think they're gonna like it. I think there's enough of what
people have come to expect from Dream Theater that they're gonna
like it, enough so that it'll lead them into the stuff that's a
little bit different.
Yeah, right. Well, that's cool. I mean, I think that's part of
doing a new album. Stay true to the identity of the band, but you
also grow and move on to something that brings in new people, and
that challenges what you want to do musically. So, that's cool.
If it strikes that balance, that's real cool.
Well, it's actually something where they've been the people who
are really into Dream Theater, and in all honesty, I haven't.
This album came, and I've been listening to it. And it's
something that, in all honesty, I'm really starting to get into.
Great, man! That's so cool.
INTERVIEW 2
Metal
Rules!!
How did four progressive rock virtuoso's come together to form
LIQUID TENSION EXPERIMENT?
MIKE PORTNOY:
Coincidentally we all live in New York. Jordan and I both live in
Rockland County and John lives on Long Island, where I used to
live and Tony lives upstate in Woodstock. That was just by
coincidence. The project actually came together when Magna Carta
approached me about the possibility of putting together a
"Super Group" of my choice and I gave them a big wish
list of all the people that I wanted to work with. Over the
course of a year or so this was the lineup that ended up
solidifying itself. We ended up do this album, writing and
recording within five days or so. It was a really wild experience.
Metal
Rules!!
One of the facts that I gleaned from my research was that you had
worked for a very long time on the DREAM THEATER record but for
only a few days on the LTE project. Does it get you a bit
frustrated that you can manage such an incredible LTE recording
in five days but it takes so much longer to put together a DREAM
THEATER record?
MP:
Well, I think that DREAM THEATER is a very different thing than
what we are doing with LTE. DREAM THEATER is A) our bread and
butter. This is what we do for a living. LTE is sorta like our
hobby. DREAM THEATER is our real job so we put a lot of time and
care into it and I think that we have been known for making
records that are very meticulous and polished so that is what
DREAM THEATER is all about. Having done a whole album in one week
I would have to say that I prefer doing it that way. I prefer
working with spontaneous ideas and recordings and stuff like
that. With DREAM THEATER's music we spent a year and a half
writing this latest album. During that process we would demo it
and re-write it and re-record it and then try it out live so that
by the time we got into the studio to record it, it was very well
rehearsed. Which can be a good thing but the bad thing is that
you lose a lot of that initial magic and spark when you are
writing the music. That was the beauty of the LTE album. We would
write something on the spot, spend a few hours putting it
together and then hit record. What you are listening to on the
album was written just hours before that so, it is as fresh as it
could be. There is a lot to be said for doing it both ways.
Metal
Rules!!
Was the title "Liquid Tension Experiment" something
that came as an after thought or was that something that you had
before the band was finalized?
MP:
Originally I was calling it "The Millennium Project"
and halfway through the record we decided to go with something
different and we had a list of stuff that we pulled from this
book that had been sitting around the studio. That is where we
got a lot of the phrases for the song titles like "Universal
Mind" and "State of Grace" and "Freedom of
Speech". Another thing that we pulled was the phrase
"Liquid Tension" and that just seemed to sum it all up
because it was liquid in the sense that everything flowed so
smoothly but it was tension because it was a very tense,
stressful process to write and record this thing in such a short
period of time. It really summed up the two extremes in this
whole project. I wanted to get the word experiment in there
because that is exactly what it was. We had no idea what was
going to become of this project. It was like putting four mice in
the studio and seeing what they would come up with.
Metal
Rules!!
When you were writing this with these three other virtuoso
musicians did ego ever become a problem? Was there ever a point
where one of you would say "I want it to go this way."
and then someone else would say "No, I think it should go
this way."?
MP:
Oh, definitely. That is part of the process of collaborating but
it all happened so quickly that there wasn't much time for much
of that. I mean, with DREAM THEATER, talk about ego's and about
going head to head! We have been writing together for a
very long time now so DREAM THEATER takes a very long time to get
the ideas from point A to point Z. There is a lot of compromising
that goes on. With this project there wasn't so much of that.
Even though all four of us have established or accomplished a lot
in our individual worlds, I would have to say that everybody
involved in this project, I won't speak for myself, but John,
Tony and Jordan are all easy going soft spoken guys. Jordan is a
bit of a perfectionist but in a good way. Jordan is not used to
collaborating where John and I are used to it and Tony is the
ultimate professional. Jordan is used to doing things his own way
because he has never been in a band so maybe for him it was a
little awkward and he would have to compromise his ideas a little
but the whole thing was so quick that there wasn't enough time
and we all went with the flow. Whatever happened, happened.
Metal
Rules!!
Have you heard the RPM CD?
MP:
Yeah. They just toured with us in Europe.
Metal
Rules!!
Jordan played with DREAM THEATER for a short time, didn't he?
MP:
He did one show with us.
Metal
Rules!!
Between RPM and DREAM THEATER did you all have occasion to jam on
this
stuff at all?
MP:
No. When Jordan and Rod were opening for us we didn't incorporate
them into the DREAM THEATER show and we should have. John Myoung
and Derrick just did a side project with Rod Morgenstein along
with Ty Tabor from KINGS X. So, when you had RUDESS/MORGENSTEIN
and DREAM THEATER on tour together you had six of the eight
members of these two projects and it was tempting to do
something. I think that in the future we might do a tour
together. Their project and our project and we would be able to
play in all of these different formations. DREAM THEATER could
play RUDESS / MORGENSTEIN could play. LTE could play. We even had
a show on this last tour in England when James became very sick
and we had to cancel the show. We tried to talk the promoter into
letting all of us play. Me, John, John, Jordan, Rod and Derrick
but it ended up not happening.
Metal
Rules!!
The promoter said "Not for this money!"
MP:
(Laughs)Yeah!
Metal
Rules!!
I know that this is just seeing the light of day but can you see
an LTE 2 or other projects where you work with other people?
MP:
I see both. Before I see a second LTE project I can see live
dates. I think that is what is next on the horizon if we were to
do anything else together. I think that would be the way to go.
Like I say, I would love to put together a tour with Derrick and
John Myoung's side project. I would love to do another album with
those guys. All four of us had a great experience with it and I
think that we would work together in a heartbeat. It's just a
matter of the timing being right. As for the second part of your
question, I think that I am also going to put together another
project similar to this one later in the year. Another sort of
"Super Group" lineup but we will see.
Metal
Rules!!
You are not going to tell me who are you?
MP:
Nope!(laughs) I have spoken to all of them and once again it is
just a matter of finding the window of opportunity.
Metal
Rules!!
Will this be another Magna Carta project?
MP:
I don't know. I will talk to them and see if they are interested
in it.
Metal
Rules!!
I was asked by someone to ask you about your relationship with
Magna Carta.
MP:
I have nothing but support for those guys. I have had a great
relationship with those guys for years. How can I say anything
bad about a label that has given me an opportunity to do an album
with Tony levin and an album with Billy Sheehan? Two people who I
love and always wanted to work with. I have a lot of respect for
what they are doing and even though it is a small label and it is
at a smaller level than what we do with Dream theater, I fully
respect the fact that they are really trying to give a lot of
these younger progressive bands an opportunity that they wouldn't
have had normally. It's a tough business and major labels are not
giving the time of day to the progressive scene so, I am very
supportive of a label that is willing to do that.
Metal
Rules!!
I have read about your disdain for the state of the music
business in general. That is something that most artist don't do,
at least publicly. Tonight, your concert is being
"presented" by a radio station that hasn't played your
music in years...
MP:
Don't get me started! I'll be flipping these guys off from the
stage tonight! I have said many bad things about the media and
radio stations and magazines and it pisses them off. I don't want
to get all off on that. It's a very frustrating business to be
in. There is a lot of politics involved and, its just
frustrating.
Metal
Rules!!
DREAM THEATER has been a group that has maintained its integrity
in that it doesn't write songs specifically so that they would
get on MTV or on the radio. Would you agree?
MP:
I think that we have been very lucky to have been able to survive
this long and to do what we do. There are always obstacles.
Making this record took longer than we would have liked because
of all the political bullshit involved but ultimately, at the end
of the day, we are proud of every one of our albums. We have done
them on our own terms and I think we have built up quite a fan
base through it. As much as I dislike major labels, the fact of
the matter is they have gotten us the recognition that a lot of
younger bands don't get because smaller label just can't do it. I
feel very fortunate that we are still able to do this for a
living. Everybody from YES to QUEENSRYCHE to MARILLION, those
guys don't even have major label deals anymore. I guess we are
pretty fortunate in that respect or unfortunate. It depends on
how you look at it!(laughs).
Metal
Rules!!
I think the finest testament to what you just said was the line
that we just passed to get onto the buss. We are still an hour
ahead of show time and the line is huge. Do you remember the days
when this wasn't the case?
MP:
Yeah. We are very fortunate. We have had a fanbase that stands by
us. This is like, a last minute tour that was only put together
about a month or so ago but the people always come out. About a
year or so ago before we went and did "Falling Into
Infinity" we went and did some dates, just some one offs to
just get out and play again. This is two or two and a half years
after our last release with nothing else in the stores yet we
sold out all the shows and that is completely do to our great
fans. They always stand by us and that is the one thing that I
absolutely love about this band is how great the fans are.
Metal
Rules!!
This summer you will be out with DEEP PURPLE and ELP. Do you
worry that this may place the image of a retro-act on yourselves?
MP:
That was our only concern with that bill. Being that they are
both from the 70's and we are from the 90's. I really think that
it should be looked at as the progressive rock heros of the past
and, hopefully, of today and tomorrow, colliding somewhere in
between. I don't think that we will be lumped in with them. I
think that we are, obviously, a young band and they have been
around for a long time. We are glad that they are taking us out
because we have been wanting a support slot for years. We have
always been headlining and doing it on our own and we have always
been looking for a band like DEEP PURPLE or YES to take us out
so, I think it will be good. Even if we do sell more records then
them of our current products, the fact of the matter is that both
of those bands are legends and big influences for us and it is
going to be amazing. Though we are all part of the progressive
rock scene their audience is much older than us and there is a
good chance that big portions of their audiences have no idea who
we are which would be some good exposure for us. We would like to
tap into some new listeners.
Metal
Rules!!
Where do you see progressive rock music heading to as a whole? I
ask because until you guys came along a few years ago the whole
progressive rock scene had become very stagnate.
MP:
Musically and creatively the progressive rock scene is bigger
than ever. All the bands that are on Magna Carta and there is a
label in Europe called Inside Out that has a lot of progressive
bands. SPOCK'S BEARD is a new band that I absolutely love. I
think that they are the best out there for this genre. So,
creatively it's bigger and better than it ever has been or at
least better than it has been in a very long time. However, as
far as it having much impact on the mainstream of music, I don't
see it having much impact because the major labels, they don't
care. They would rather be signing THE PRODIGY or the SPICE GIRLS
and the quick sell. We are the only young progressive band that I
can think of that even has that level of exposure. As long as the
major labels are going to be that closed minded, it's going to be
a rough ride.
Metal
Rules!!
What does the immediate future hold for you?
MP:
I think that we will probably put out some new live material in
the fall. Maybe a live home video but that is still in the works.
That's what is going on with DREAM THEATER. As far as LTE, like I
said, I would love to be able to put together some type of tour.
maybe in the fall or winter depending on every bodies schedule.
INTERVIEW 3
With the release of their fourth full-length album, Falling Into Infinity, Dream Theater are steadily becoming the new leaders of prog-rock. The band has attained an enormous legion of loyal fans worldwide that continues to grow stronger album after album. Over the last decade, this musically masterminded quintet has managed to remain unaffected by the shifting winds of trend, with their latest release venturing into even deeper, unknown territory. From their breakthrough 1992 release, Images And Words, to 1994's follow-up Awake, to 1995's partial live set A Change Of Seasons, the band has always conceptualized their music with their audience in mind. I recently caught up with DT bassist John Myung to discuss the group's ever-growing success.
SW: Let's talk about your latest release
Falling Into Infinity (EastWest /Elektra); how would you say this
record differs from your previous releases musically?
John: I think we've concentrated more on the songwriting with
this album, whereas our previous songs had a lot of twists and
turns.
SW: Was this album written with the
intention of making the songs more marketable?
John: I would seem to think so.
SW: Not many people are aware that Dream
Theater's debut came out in 1989 on the Mechanic/MCA label...have
you maintained the same lineup since that release?
John: Myself, Mike Portnoy, and John Petrucci have remained,
since then we got a new singer and keyboard player.
SW: What was the band doing between 1989
and the release of your Atco/EastWest debut, Images And Words, in
1992? The band seemed to have disappeared...
John: We were in our basement studio writing a lot, refining our
songs. We decided not to go the club circuit route, we rehearsed
Monday through Friday and really concentrated on our material.
After the release of Images and Words, we hit the road for about
18 months.
SW: The second track, "You Not
Me," was co-written with Desmond Child, who is known as the
"'80s rock hit-maker," most notably from his
involvement with Bon Jovi's biggest hit singles...what prompted
you to collaborate with Desmond?
John: It was our relationship with Kevin Shirley (the producer).
Kevin had just finished up with the new Aerosmith record, and he
had worked with Desmond on that. He heard "You Not Me,"
and he felt it needed a stronger, more powerful chorus. So,
Desmond and John Petrucci did a rough demo and Desmond
reinterpreted the lyrics and collaborated with John on the
music...the chord progressions. He stripped down the song to give
it more of a straight-ahead chorus. This was the first song Dream
Theater ever wrote with someone outside of the band.
SW: Was it a good first-time experience,
especially to work with someone as famous as Desmond Child?
John: Well, it's a learning experience. You hear what Desmond has
done in the past with bands like Aerosmith, Bon Jovi, and even
now with Hansen, and you tend to wonder, "What is his
magic?"; and it is actually very much what we do, and that
is, try a lot of options and find out which one works the best.
SW: In your bio, it describes that song
as a "tortured love anthem"... can you explain the
meaning behind that? Or is that just the record company's
perception of it?
John: I think that's the record company being a little bit too
creative.
SW: "Lines In The Sand" is a
really great song. I noticed it features King's X vocalist Doug
Pinnick. How did that come about?
John: We heard this melody when we were writing the song and we
decided to give Doug a call because he is one of our favorite
singers and he's been a friend of ours for quite a while. He was
really happy that we thought of him, so we flew him to New York
to record it. It was amazing working with him, he is a true
professional...he just came right in and banged it out.
SW: The music we hear today on the
radio, and what is covered in the media, has changed quite
drastically within the last five years, at least here in the US,
making it, nowadays, extremely difficult for a talented hard rock
band such as Dream Theater to get national recognition. Yet in
Europe, and Japan, Dream Theater records have gone multi-Platinum
and the band headlines large arenas. Why do you think foreign
countries have taken such a liking to Dream Theater as opposed to
here in your homeland?
John: Good question...the climate is really different over there,
whereas here, there's many different ways for people to get
information. There's many different video channels, and radio in
general is pretty huge out here, whereas over there it's more
streamlined...there are very few radio stations dedicated to hard
rock. I see the music over there is more built on relationships,
people are really into following the groups, whereas the
state-of-mind over here changes from year to year. Although we do
have a following here in the States, but it's more of a cult
following. The Internet has been very good in keeping them
informed on what the band is doing.
SW: Speaking of the Internet...we
interviewed Geoff Tate; and he also stated that Queensryche
maintains much of their fan base by utilizing the Internet. And,
like Queensryche, Dream Theater has maintained a very loyal fan
base through these so-called "alternative" years. It
seems as though the Internet is one of the only means of
promoting a new CD from a hard rock/metal band...apart from
rigorous touring.
John: Well, the Internet has been the most useful as far as
getting the information out to our fans. For our previous albums,
Awake and Images and Words, it was very press heavy. The Internet
has opened up a whole new way for any diehard fan to get
information on us. It has really changed things a lot and has
really helped us in promoting our new record.
SW: Progressive rock is still very
popular today...in fact, the reunited Styx recently sold out
three nights at Universal Amphitheater here in LA. Bands like
Yes, Rush and Queensryche are still headlining arenas...and Dream
Theater also sells out large venues. What do you feel contributes
to the success and the demand for progressive rock, despite the
lack of media coverage?
John: I think it's the type of relationship the fans have with
the artists, it's not something that will go away just because
radio or MTV decides not to play it, it goes beyond that. These
fans really look forward to hearing a new record, whether or not
MTV plays your videos.
SW: Bands such as Styx, Kansas, Rush,
Yes, ELP...obviously they attract an older audience, generally 30
years plus. Even though Dream Theater is not a band from the
seventies, your music is much more sophisticated than the average
rock band of the nineties, and you, too, also attract a somewhat
older audience. Do you feel that there is potential in this day
and age to market your style of music to today's teenagers?
John: It really depends on who has the most money and clout...it
takes someone to really step in and spend mega-dollars to keep
you popular. And I don't really see that happening, I see it more
as us taking matters into our own hands.
SW: Are you agreeing that the music
industry today has become much more a business than a love for
music?
John: Yes. There's always that side to it. You know, we're not
Michael Jackson or someone, where millions of dollars are spent
to keep up his popularity. We're totally on the opposite side of
the spectrum when it comes to that, because we don't really write
songs that are formatted for Top 40.
SW: There have been certain people in
the industry who claim that everything in music has come around
full-circle, and that a new "progessive" musical
revolution will soon emerge into the mainstream...what are your
thoughts?
John: It's possible...I mean, what other options do you have?
(slight laughter).
SW: What music business advice would you
give to a young band today that is just starting out?
John: The way I see it is, it's really tough to be a musician
because the overhead is really expensive when you think in
practical terms of being able to pay for your gear, pay for your
health insurance, and whatever else. It can be really
frustrating. You have to really keep things in
perspective...especially your finances. A lot of businesses feed
off the industry, or off the musicians themselves, whether it be
attorneys, recording studios, tour bus companies, the promoters,
or booking agents...it's very hard to do well for yourself when
you have all these different industries that evolve around you
and take a piece of what you do. It really pays to have a good
understanding of the financial and business aspects when it comes
to your career. I've made mistakes, and I've paid for them. I
don't know if it's so much different from when I first started to
where it is now, it's just that now I am that much more aware of
everything that is going on on a business level.